Pictures of Edsa Dos.
A lot of people who supported edsa dos 5 years ago, have changed their views lately. Pero wag mo raw silang tawagin na hypokrito.
Me, I supported Edsa One, but not Two.
UPDATE: Sabi ni MLQ3:
Edsa Tres had no leaders on the front lines, and no clergy to counsel peaceful protest. It became an attack on the Bastille that failed.
Edsa tres had no military support too, that's why it failed.
But that being the case, our fate will be decided in only one of two ways: a coup, or charter change. In both cases, most civilians will be on the sidelines as things play out.
Coup, huh? hindi na "people power" ang tawag, unlike edsa one and two? I guess bawal nang gamitin ang Edsa TM.
Related:
-- Defending Edsa Dos (posted: August 20, 2005)
UPDATE: UPDATE: From Randy David:
IT is amazing how People Power, a form of non-violent political action that Filipinos accidentally developed in their struggle against a dictatorship, has suddenly become an embarrassment to its inventors. Rather than draw strength and renewed commitment from its remembrance, those who mounted it, only feel disgust now. Its prime beneficiaries—those who came to power on its wings—fear it above all. Instead of heroism, they associate it with recklessness. Instead of the sacrifice, they only see the bid for power. Unable to praise it, they denigrate it. Such is the tragedy of people power.
A group of activists from Akbayan and Laban ng Masa dutifully showed up the other day at the People Power Monument, with placards bearing the single message: "Spirit of Edsa betrayed by Gloria." Implicit in that note at least is a continuing belief in some Edsa spirit, however we may understand it. In contrast, Malacanang would rather forget all about Edsa. Presidential Spokesman Ignacio Bunye says "the people are losing faith in people power," dismissing it as "reckless gambles at power." How perspectives shift with time!
"Reckless gambles of power"???? UN-FUCKING-BELIEVABLE!!! HINDI BA KAYO AT ANG BOSS MO ANG NAKINABANG SA EDSA DOS, MR. BUNYE???
More from Ellen Tordesillas. I recall Ellen writing a best-selling book detailing Erap's excesses, so Ellen's not exactly an Erap supporter here (Just like Arroyo-critics JB Baylon and Conrad De Quiros).
But compared to Erap, I guess Arroyo's worse.
(I myself was VERY anti-Erap before and did not vote for him in the 1998 elections, but I found out later na mas malala at hypocritical pa pala yung mga kaaway niya. "Sugal, alak, babae"? Puh-lease. So yung galit ko kay erap, lumipat sa kaaway niya--which is really nakakagulat because I never liked erap from the beginning anyways.)
And Mike Arroyo remembers Edsa Dos.
UPDATE:
Last Friday was the fifth anniversary of Edsa Dos that installed Arroyo in MalacaƱang without having been elected to the position. Not a word from MalacaƱang extolling the spirit of Edsa Dos as was their practice the last four years.
Hah, I agree. Nung Jan. 20, 2005, Malacanang released a press statement in observance of Edsa Dos 4th anniversary, where Arroyo, in a radio interview, said Edsa Dos' message was about "fighting graft which has also already corrupted our culture."
President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo said today’s observance of the 4th EDSA Dos anniversary is an opportune time for Filipinos to talk about how the country fared economically since she took over the national leadership four years ago.
EDSA Dos refers to that fateful day on January 20, 2001 when then President Joseph Estrada left Malacanang in response to the Filipinos’ demands for his resignation on account of his alleged involvement in massive graft and economic plunder.
Estrada was then on impeachment trial by the Senate. The day before, his majority Senate allies blocked the opening of the Jose Velarde bank documents that first person witness Clarissa Ocampo said were opened and personally signed by him in her presence.
In an interview over radio station DZEC, Mrs. Arroyo said EDSA Dos’ message then and now remains basically the same: "We have to fight graft which has also already corrupted our culture" and which has made the country an economic laggard for decades now.
LOL.
More from Ellen:
Since Arroyo wants to abolish People Power with her Preemptive Calibrated Response, we would like to remind her how she extolled it on Jan. 20, 2001 at the Edsa Shrine when she took her oath before then Chief Justice Hilario Davide. Her words:
“..I pray that we will all be one – one in our priorities, one in our values and commitments, and one because of Edsa 2001.
“People Power and the ‘oneness’ of will and vision have made a new beginning possible.
“As we break from the past in our quest for a new Philippines, the unity, the Filipino’s sense of history, and his unshakeable faith in the Almighty that prevailed in EDSA ’86 and EDSA 2001 will continue to guide and inspire us.
“I am certain that Filipinos of unborn generations will look back with pride to EDSA 2001, just as we look back with pride to Mactan, the Katipunan and other revolts, Bataan and Corregidor, and EDSA ’86.
“People Power has dramatized the Filipino’s capacity for greatness.
“People of People Power, I ask for your support and prayers. Together, we will light the healing and cleaning flame.”
The whole speech is posted in Bunye’s website: www.news.ops.gov.ph
The speech can also be accessed here.
UPDATE: Tignan nyo yung nakalagay ngayon sa website ni Bunye dated Jan 20, 2006. Heh.
2 comments:
in those early morning hours, if those attacking the palace had had proper leadership, they could have stormed the palace and, after a bloodbath, possibly lynched the president.
I disagree. Without the military component, wala rin. No guns, no glory.
people power requires people, and there's no people willing to go out and do people power. not yet. so, it can't be an edsa.
again, i disagree. preparado ang admin ngayon na gumamit ng violence para i-disperse ang mga anti-arroyo rallies with their "no permit, no rally" rule and CPR.
besides, totoo yung sinabi ni mike defensor, it's not going to be as peaceful as the last time, kahit na maraming nang civilians nasa kalsada para patalsikin si arroyo. ready ang admin sa patayan to protect their illegitimate rule.
eto ang ipinost ko dati:
Having said that though, I fear na magiging madugo ang susunod na "Edsa." More Tiananmen (China) and less "Orange Revolution" (Ukraine). It's Arroyo's military loyalists and the remaining few pro-GMA members of Civil Society vs. the People. And the longer she stays in power, the worse it will become for our country.
if only GMA would do the right thing and resign... sigh...
the erap and ping opposition are welcoming the possibility of a coup.
tell me, mlq3 atin atin lang ito... is that what you are telling your blog readers, using erap and lacson as bogeymen, to scare them off from supporting any attempt to oust GMA? kasi kung ganyan ang kaso, that's very disappointing...
no, it's what the opposition leaders themselves are dealing with.
And I think you're wrong.
and what we should know, because if you are going to go down the path of wanting the soldiers to solve things, you'd better know what you're getting into.
gusto ko lang linawin ang isang bagay, manuel--I'm not in favor of any military junta, but i'm in favor of removing GMA via the so called "constructive resignation".
once she's out, hindi lang yung mga COMELEC commissioners ang magre-resign, pero PATI na rin yung mga lower ranking COMELEC officials na involved sa GLORIAGATE scandal (hindi ito kasali sa petition nyo to reform the COMELEC, IIRC, which is a one of it's BIG pagkukulangs, IMO... I will deal with that later in a future post).
Kapag maayos na ulit ang COMELEC, then we will have new elections to elect a legit president. But no junta for me, MLQ3.
re: wanting the soldiers to solve things for us
I don't want the soldiers "to solve" the GLORIAGATE crisis for us. And I don't want to see them take the PRIMARY role in ousting GMA.
But do I want them involved in future "people power" moves against Arroyo? DEFINITELY.
I want them to play a SUPPORT role in ousting a corrupt and illegitimate president like they did in Edsa 1986 (where sila ang nauna at nag-spark ng edsa revolt) or in Edsa Dos (where kumalas sila kay erap after medyo malaki na ang mga anti-erap crowd sa edsa noong 2001).
And yes, dapat tayong mag-ingat sa mga self-coup na yan, since the people around arroyo and the people surrounding the marcoses then think alike. we know Arroyo's people and supporters are ruthless and cold blooded. And it doesn't hurt arroyo na she is already close friends with imelda, so maraming tips na maibibigay si imelda marcos kay GMA on "coup me" tactics.
re mlq3 "you'd better know what you're getting into."
hahahaha, thanks for your concern Manuel... but i'll be taking some tips from Mike ARroyo on how to form a military "strike force". ;)
Post a Comment